Steer Planet - Show Steers and Club Calves Forum

Steer Planet Chat => The Big Show => Topic started by: Okotoks on June 22, 2019, 06:20:56 PM

Title: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on June 22, 2019, 06:20:56 PM
Here are the three bulls seeing service on the cow herd at Diamond Shorthorns this year.
Diamond Belvedere 29B sired by The Grove Kookaburra W735 out of Diamond Dottie 55G.
Saskvalley Curfew 41C sired by Saskvalley Alamo 8A out of Saskvalley Blossom 295A
Diamond Dynamite 6D sired by Diamond Lord Belmore 56B and out of Diamond Britney Maid 2B. (He will head back to Woodruff Ranches in July)
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: mbigelow on June 22, 2019, 11:21:11 PM
Those are some good looking bulls! I really like the style of the curfew bull and the depth,mass and muscle of belvedere.   
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: idalee on June 23, 2019, 07:06:56 AM
What would their frame scores be?
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on June 23, 2019, 12:42:35 PM
What would their frame scores be?
Saskvalley Curfew 41C was a frame 6 when he was younger, I am not sure if he would still be that as a mature bull. Diamond Dynamite 6D is probably a 6.5 and I am guessing Diamond Belvedere 29B is a 7 but I have not measured them.
Here are some calves by Belvedere 29B.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: idalee on June 23, 2019, 03:41:22 PM
Thank you.   I like them even better now!   It is easy to breed cattle smaller, but more difficult to keep them large.   Small framed cattle,  if they have the kind of gain we need,  start to look like pigs.   Rick Pisaturo,  of Mandalong fame,  expressed the opinion that bulls need to be a frame score one or two higher than the cows he is mated with to maintain frame and size in the herd.   
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 24, 2019, 09:23:17 AM
When you say it is easy to make them smaller are you talking pounds or inches?  I have been trying to downsize for 25 years, I have got rid of some frame but not many pounds.  I guess I might like cattle that resemble pigs as they are very easy keepers.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Willow Springs on June 24, 2019, 10:07:06 AM
Nice bulls Dan - especially like the looks of the Belvedere bull - and getting a bit off topic in response to Idalee and Beebe; several years ago we weighed, did hip heights and body condition scored all the 3 year and older cows (about 50) to get a baseline of where we were. We found that our cows (Red Angus) were on average 1490 lbs with a frame score of 5.6 and BCS of CDN 3 or US 5.4 (these are exact averages). This data was taken in early November at preg checking when we still calved in February, weaned in early September and had cows going back to grass so they had a bit more rig on them.

A few things we found - when adjusted for BCS cows of a certain HH were very close in bodyweight. A frame score 5 cow in our herd was still about 1450 lbs if they were built with the volume and mass I liked.

Now to Idalees point - we made the decision on this info that our cattle were a bit too big and heavy so I made a point of only using sub 5 frame bulls for a few years. This combined with a change to less intensive management and calving season change led to very small first calving cows and young cows to the point that their calves were smaller and stubbier. This in some cases meant that I got less per pound for these calves and in others that I needed to feed more calves for the winter to get them to more profitable weights or body type. We have since gone to using larger bulls again but trying to stay in the 5.5-6 frame range as mature animals, and combined with management our cows are still moderate for our environment. I think Mr Pisaturos observations are correct in my experience.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Duncraggan on June 24, 2019, 12:30:13 PM
D. Dynamite 6D would be my choice!
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on June 26, 2019, 10:26:21 AM
Nice bulls Dan - especially like the looks of the Belvedere bull - and getting a bit off topic in response to Idalee and Beebe; several years ago we weighed, did hip heights and body condition scored all the 3 year and older cows (about 50) to get a baseline of where we were. We found that our cows (Red Angus) were on average 1490 lbs with a frame score of 5.6 and BCS of CDN 3 or US 5.4 (these are exact averages). This data was taken in early November at preg checking when we still calved in February, weaned in early September and had cows going back to grass so they had a bit more rig on them.

A few things we found - when adjusted for BCS cows of a certain HH were very close in bodyweight. A frame score 5 cow in our herd was still about 1450 lbs if they were built with the volume and mass I liked.

Now to Idalees point - we made the decision on this info that our cattle were a bit too big and heavy so I made a point of only using sub 5 frame bulls for a few years. This combined with a change to less intensive management and calving season change led to very small first calving cows and young cows to the point that their calves were smaller and stubbier. This in some cases meant that I got less per pound for these calves and in others that I needed to feed more calves for the winter to get them to more profitable weights or body type. We have since gone to using larger bulls again but trying to stay in the 5.5-6 frame range as mature animals, and combined with management our cows are still moderate for our environment. I think Mr Pisaturos observations are correct in my experience.
I agree with his observations as well. You make a good point about the size of calves, in our part of the world most cattle will be finished in the feedlot and how they perform there really drives the demand. It is a balancing act between getting the most pounds from the cow calf operation with minimum inputs and then getting good gains in the feedlot with good feed conversion.
Here is another Belvedere heifer calf born March 23 out of a three old daughter of Herbourne B Manitoba Gus 13Z.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 26, 2019, 11:50:54 PM
I  sure don't want to disrespect anyone's cattle or choices in what type of cattle they choose to raise.  However I think there is a fair amount of research that indicates that smaller cows will wean more pounds per acre.  Smaller calves tend to bring more per pound, so if you have more pounds per acre and they sell for more per pound, it seems like there might be some additional profit.  But to each there own.   
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: oakview on June 27, 2019, 09:01:02 AM
Long live Lowlines and Miniature Herefords?  Anyone who lived through 800 pound cows and belt buckle bulls weaning 300 pound calves sure doesn't want to go back there.  You want to bring back Prince Eric of Sunbeam and Louada Aristocrat have at it.  Maybe 1,700 pound cows aren't the answer, but neither are 800 pounders.  Surely there's a happy medium.  I guess I prefer the return/investment approach.  Around here, the smaller calves sell for more per bound because the feeders think they can put on the pounds cheaper than they can buy it.  1.70/lb for a 450 pounder versus 1.70/pound for an 800 pounder?  I think you can put on those 350 pounds for less than 1.70/pound.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 27, 2019, 10:44:38 AM
My goal is a frame score 4 1250 pound cow that weans at least half her weight.  I have many that can do that.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: oakview on June 27, 2019, 03:29:53 PM
I have no quarrel with a 1,250 pound cow that weans a calf weighing 600 pounds.  To me, that's the happy medium I was describing.  We should all be so lucky!  When the word "smaller" was used, those miserable cows of the 60's came to mind.  Sorry.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 27, 2019, 05:47:01 PM
I still would like to know whether smaller is inches or pounds?  Or both.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Willow Springs on June 27, 2019, 06:21:31 PM
Beebe, I agree that smaller cows are more profitable per acre. The smaller the cow the better in those terms, and sheep are even more profitable per acre.

However different environments, body composition, time of weighing, BCS, feed the cattle are on all affect body weight. A 4 frame cow here was not 1250 lbs when we weighed, but they had 3 months to fatten up post weaning prior to the winter. If I weighed them at weaning they would have been much lighter, but once adjusted for BCS they would have basically been the same weight I reported because those were adjusted for BCS - so a 4 frame mature cow here would be in the 1350-1400 lb range with reasonable body condition. Unless your cows are smaller they would likely be the same - unless they are finer made and lacking capacity which I doubt by the pictures I have seen of your cattle.

And also those smaller cows are only more profitable if the calves are selling like the bigger calves. As I said some of the calves from those smaller bulls were coming out a bit stubby and were docked at the sale barn - so the advantage is lost. Also our environment is tougher on those light calves if having to feed through the winter so I prefer to have them at a weight where I can just market them in the fall. Lastly in Western Canada light calves have been selling at a substantial discount to heavier calves in the last two years - especially in the last year due to drought and feed shortages.

So general rules are great and are a good guideline, but a person also has adjust to what is actually happening.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 27, 2019, 09:31:33 PM
I agree completely.  We have to stay light on our feet.  I say 1250 but my perfect cow that I thought was a 4 and 1250 turned out to be 1390 on the day we weaned her calf at 720.  She stays at about the same flesh all year.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: mark tenenbaum on June 28, 2019, 12:24:05 PM
My goal is a frame score 4 1250 pound cow that weans at least half her weight.  I have many that can do that.
//// TELL PHARO about those cows and make sure you admit they are all his idea-LOL O0 <rock>



Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: beebe on June 28, 2019, 06:54:17 PM
I have not talked to Kit in years, I do agree with what he thinks, I think he wants an 1100 pound cow.  The research done by Eric Mousel at South Dakota State University confirmed that the path I was on would be more profitable for me.  Also Kris Ringwal  at North Dakota reinforces Eric's findings.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on June 28, 2019, 07:11:10 PM
D. Dynamite 6D would be my choice!
Here are some Diamond Dynamite 6D yearling heifers. They were born April, May last year, mostly out of Angus x charolais or Angus x Shorthorn cows.
There are some nice purebred heifers by him as well. We are using a red son of 6D on a group of whites and light roan yearling heifers as well.
Dynamite's dam weighed 1400 lbs as a three year old weaning her second calf little late as we showed the pair. (pictured) The next photo is shortly after calving as a two year old with Dynamite and the next is of them at weaning.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: mark tenenbaum on June 28, 2019, 10:06:32 PM
powerfull cow-Are the  Shorthorn  x char -angus cross 2 heifers in the foreground of the 4 pictured?-the closest one in front with her head down is my favorite of the whole post other than dynomites dam
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: ska on June 29, 2019, 12:22:30 AM
nice cows!  O0
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: aj on June 29, 2019, 07:42:08 AM
Looks like to me that a cow that is just big enough to raise a calf that is big enough for the packers would be a nice size. And if you want to get really crazy.......animal science common sense crazy....have a moderate cow bred to a terminal trait bull. Why in the world Angus or Shorthorn people would want 1500 pound cows is beyond me. I guess that if the average cow herd size is 5o head or less...they can't use this crossbreeding system though.......so it doesn't matter I guess.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Medium Rare on June 29, 2019, 09:21:30 AM
Is Diamond Belvedere 29B semen available in the states?  Did they ever get the Australian data into digital beef?

I ran my yearling Lord Belmore son on some heifers this spring. He's sure looking the part.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Duncraggan on June 29, 2019, 04:05:35 PM
D. Dynamite 6D would be my choice!
Here are some Diamond Dynamite 6D yearling heifers. They were born April, May last year, mostly out of Angus x charolais or Angus x Shorthorn cows.
There are some nice purebred heifers by him as well. We are using a red son of 6D on a group of whites and light roan yearling heifers as well.
Dynamite's dam weighed 1400 lbs as a three year old weaning her second calf little late as we showed the pair. (pictured) The next photo is shortly after calving as a two year old with Dynamite and the next is of them at weaning.
The third picture really tells the story. The wean size is amazing!
Superb bunch of x-bred heifers. Very even Shorthorn look, considering they have Charolais about them!
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on June 30, 2019, 11:36:13 PM
Looks like to me that a cow that is just big enough to raise a calf that is big enough for the packers would be a nice size. And if you want to get really crazy.......animal science common sense crazy....have a moderate cow bred to a terminal trait bull. Why in the world Angus or Shorthorn people would want 1500 pound cows is beyond me. I guess that if the average cow herd size is 5o head or less...they can't use this crossbreeding system though.......so it doesn't matter I guess.
They did it with broiler chickens...and this article about salmon is a bit scary! Not sure a regular breeder lives long enough to create "the perfect profitable cow" for all environments
https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-first-genetically-modified-animals-approved-for-us-consumption-are-here-2019-06-21?fbclid=IwAR3rW7i8E8zDV6vz3qwAQQqBaAi5y9VzaI5OWJniTQRZoW5M4o65vrQLM00 (https://www.marketwatch.com/story/the-first-genetically-modified-animals-approved-for-us-consumption-are-here-2019-06-21?fbclid=IwAR3rW7i8E8zDV6vz3qwAQQqBaAi5y9VzaI5OWJniTQRZoW5M4o65vrQLM00)
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: shortybreeder on July 01, 2019, 07:35:51 PM
There is research out there supporting the claims that you can regulate mature size by controlling feed intake through heifer development while still getting healthy calves out of 2 year old heifers. So maybe instead of focusing on breeding the performance out of our cattle, we need to focus on finding that balance point between feeding for physiological development and physical development. I believe you can have cows with the genetic potential of 1500-1600lb mature weights but actual mature weights of 1400-1450lbs.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: aj on July 02, 2019, 07:52:53 AM
As far as "breeding performance out of cattle" is concerned......  Stayability is performance. Producing a calf every year without a pickup load of artificial protein supplements is performance. If I am feeding cattle in the feedlot or selling protein supplements to the cow-calf guy....i would love the 1500 pound cow. The calves gain better in the feedlot.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: mark tenenbaum on July 02, 2019, 06:38:31 PM
THATS right-and they can have a big calf if it happens-that will wean of weighing more than the others and yield more pounds in the end O0
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on July 02, 2019, 10:54:36 PM
powerfull cow-Are the  Shorthorn  x char -angus cross 2 heifers in the foreground of the 4 pictured?-the closest one in front with her head down is my favorite of the whole post other than dynomites dam
I got it a bit wrong Mark. The front heifer does have a little Charolais in her but it's away back. Her dam was a Shorthorn x Angus with a bit of Charolais. The other heifers are out of Shorthorn Angus or Angus cows.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on July 02, 2019, 11:30:27 PM
One of our junior herd sires this year is Hatfield Bingo 2F.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on July 03, 2019, 10:34:42 PM
Another young bull owned by Woodruff Ranches that we were able to use on a group of heifers that were bred AI first. He is now with the Diamond Dynamite daughters. He had a 63 lb birth weight. Janell's Falcon 70F by Muridale President 33B and out of a cow by Muridale Tradition 115Y.
A bit of rain and I was able to get a better photo of Falcon today taking the first one down, it doesn't do him justice.
Title: Re: Our senior herd sires for 2019
Post by: Okotoks on July 11, 2019, 04:31:12 PM
Is Diamond Belvedere 29B semen available in the states?  Did they ever get the Australian data into digital beef?

I ran my yearling Lord Belmore son on some heifers this spring. He's sure looking the part.
The Australians have run in the test phase of IGS but they have not gone live with yet as far as I can find out. I think that is why some of the accuracy numbers on Australian animals went up though.
Diamond Belvedere 29B will be collected later this year hopefully there will be some US qualified. Glad the Lord Belmore bull is doing well. We used two sons on afew this year plus have quite a few two year old and yearling daughters. They have been easy calving and good mothers! Pictured is one two year old last spring with her Diamond Dundee 26D bull calf born March 6.