Take aways from 2014 NWSS fat steer show

Help Support Steer Planet:

RankeCattleCo

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
715
Location
Southeastern Wisconsin
Was anybody out to see the fat steer show today? I followed Matt's Twitter and website tonight pretty heavily to keep up on class winners and such. To be completely honest.. I thought the competition was really lacking this year. Obviously wasn't there but from the pictures it didn't seem like there was one "perfect" steer. Did really like the grand overall and the more and more I looked at May's reserve I liked that one more. Sired by The Colonel so that was a bit of a twist.. What were all of your thoughts?
 

Warrior10

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2010
Messages
1,653
Location
Mason City, Ne
I've only seen/heard of two "Colonel" calves last couple years and both were studs...wonder why don't see others. I really liked the Grand and Reserve. I thought the division 3 champ was a powerful and meaty steer, but I didn't see him walk and something with his back 1/3 just looks different (just watching the blog like yourself). I liked the profile of the red and white class 6 winner, but I don't like he had enough power/flank depth to contend for grand/reserve. I wish I could find some pictures of the breed winners, any suggestions?
 

chambero

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2007
Messages
3,207
Location
Texas
I watched the live video a little bit (med wt crossbred champion, some of the heavies, and overall).  Reserve overall looked much better on video than I think the photos do.  The class winners I watched all looked fine, but the grand overall drive looked like a fairly easy decision.

Isn't the British breed supposed to be registered purebreeds?  The champ British is already getting advertised as a MAB.
 

OhioKid

Active member
Joined
Feb 26, 2013
Messages
29
chambero said:
I watched the live video a little bit (med wt crossbred champion, some of the heavies, and overall).  Reserve overall looked much better on video than I think the photos do.  The class winners I watched all looked fine, but the grand overall drive looked like a fairly easy decision.

Isn't the British breed supposed to be registered purebreeds?  The champ British is already getting advertised as a MAB.

Don't hold me too it, but I believe he may have been Shorthorn Plus.
 

RankeCattleCo

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2011
Messages
715
Location
Southeastern Wisconsin
The more i studied the grand the more I liked him. Real powerful guy. Lautner doesn't even list The Colonel as a sire in their directory anymore. Isn't he a clone to a winning steer himself?
 

Davidsonranch

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 2, 2011
Messages
443
Location
SE Oregon
Per an old threat on Steerplanet:
"Phil Lautner says: GC: Colonel was a clone to a steer that Mike Trienen raised"
 

Davidsonranch

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 2, 2011
Messages
443
Location
SE Oregon
TheColonel.jpg


From Bull Barn Genetics page
The Colonel:
In 2005, we took Chance's last show steer to Kansas City with high hopes. Unfortunately, Tiffany Pruitt brought a Heat Wave steer that dominated our class and looked to us to be Grand Champion caliber. We purchased the steer through the sale that night and pulled DNA. Now you have a chance to breed to this all-time crowd favorite. The first calves have hit the ground and are super stout and stylish.
 

InIt2WinIt

Active member
Joined
Jun 14, 2011
Messages
31
Here are my takeaways from Denver:

1. I did not care for the reserve. Plain fronted, frail boned, short bodied, not that stout. I'm not the only guy who felt this way. Numerous big time steer guys expressed that same sentiment. I recall one saying: "There are 20 other steers in the barn I'd use over him."

2. The Jones steer that stood second to Bonhams in class was a GOOD dude. Cool look, sound, stout, and very attractive from the side. Personally, I would have used him to win the whole thing with Bonham reserve. I can't argue too much with Bonham winning cuz that steer was very good as well.

3. I don't like the three judge panel system. One: it takes WAY TOO LONG. Two: It annoys the hell out of me how often the judges would get on the microphone and start by saying, "We were unanimous in our decision..." Three: The system kills some of the thrill inherent to the show ring with one judge. Four: Reasons suffer greatly when a judge is forced to talk on behalf of how the system placed the steers and not his own placing. So, let's please go back to one judge. I admire the NWSS for trying something new, but I hope they recognize it as an inferior system and adapt accordingly.

4. There wasn't that killer good perfect steer out there. There was a lot of really good steers but you were able to pick some minor holes in all of them. Then again, you have to keep it in perspective. Steers like that 2012 Fort Worth champ don't come around that often.

5. I like Denver as a breed show. Hopefully it will help boost numbers in years to come. Denver will never rival Fort Worth in numbers but I think reaching the 400-450 head count is realistic if the sale stays strong. There's no reason for it not to be bigger because, after all, it is the toughest/most prestigious show there is that isn't in Texas. Maybe allowing steers that don't make sale to go home would get more Texans to come north???

Just my two cents here. Not trying to offend anyone.
 

Latest posts

Top