Kirk's as fair as anyone, IMO. I can see good hair being an advantage showing to him, especially in showmanship - Kirk's a very big advocate of exhibitors putting plenty of time and effort in their cattle, and hair's one big way that shows. I believe Kirk kind of judges along the lines of remembering the first word in show calf is show - fresh, fancy, well presented cattle will have an advantage. There's nothing wrong with that as long as a judge is fair and consistent, which I believe him to be.