I plan on using Hillside Leader on many of our heifers, as his calves so far have been all unassisted. I think there is still a place for some growth bulls in the breed. In regards to using Salute, as I have said before, my experience with his calves has been excellent. I have only had 6 Salute calves in total, and all were unassisted with BWs between 85 lbs and 105 lbs. Timeline was the heaviest at 105 lbs.There were also 2 full sib bulls to Timeline and the owners of these two bulls report no calving issues. Both were very happy with the calving ease and the growth in the calves. I have actually received phone calls from commercial producers asking me why I do not have more Salute bulls in our bull sale.
Like most people, I am in this business to make a living, but I am not willing to ruin the breed to do that. If I was convinced that Salute was the evil satanic sire of all time, I would probably be amongst the first to discard his offspring. I have walked away from bulls that I had much more to lose than a few straws of semen, because I did not think they were going to offer anything to the breed. I have sold Salute embryos to Britain and they love the calves. They want more of them. No calving issues and they have had some calving issues from the some of the lowest BW EPD bulls in the breed.
I doubt if I will use any more Salute semen, except for a possible flush where they want Salute used. I will however, use our Timeline bull, who is a Salute son, and who is siring excellent offspring. The second calf crop is now arriving and reports so far are excellent. I have only heard of one assist and that was from a heifer so far. His calves have style and performance and so far they have been very popular with purebred and commercial producers alike.
Maybe if I had more faith that the numbers being generated were totally accurate, I would change my opinion. Believe me, I have tried to study the EPDs extensively, and the more I study them, the more convinced I am that they are not accurate enough to make breeding decisions with, especially with the CE EPDs. There is so much more involved in calving ease than just BW. I wrote about a conversation I had with one of the largest order buyers in these parts, last fall. He said that he felt that the industries obsession with low BWs was ruining his ability to put pot loads of similar calves together. As he said, a calf that is 2 inches shorter will probably be lighter at birth. He said there are far too many short bodied calves coming through the sale barns. I assisted my vet do a c section when the owner of the cow could not assist ( he was outside with his head between his knees) I could not believe the small size of this calf and we weighed it. It was a whopping 82 lbs and it came out the side. It had a head almost as wide as the mother's and there was no way it would come out the normal way. But that is just how I see it. As I am typing this calves # 64 and 65 are in the process of being born here. So far, I have assisted one cow calve, and it was a dead calf and she just would not get down to business and calve it. These calves have been from several sires with a wide array of CE EPDs. There have been some variations in birth weights, but so far the heaviest calf was 102 lbs. It has been a good calving season so far for me, and I would not change a thing. Maybe the big ones are yet to come, or maybe they are coming as I type this.