Butterfat Content Galloway Milk

Help Support Steer Planet:

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
I have been trying to get information on the butterfat content in Galloway milk.
Seems like this would be a research topic for some college type.
There does seem to be correlation between high butterfat and marbling, marbling being heritable at something like 0.40, and I wonder if the butterfat heritability is similar. Interesting that the fat particles in the Galloway milk, like those in the muscle, are fine and diffuse. ( in this one remote example, anyway)
https://books.google.com/books?id=txc3AQAAIAAJ&pg=PA405&dq=galloway+milk&hl=en&sa=X&ei=IDiNVMaeNMyIsQT7iYDoAw&ved=0CDkQ6AEwBQ#v=onepage&q=galloway%20milk&f=false
p 405
In my personal experience for the last twenty years, I find Galloways equal as butter-producing animals to any of the beef breeds, writes Mr. R. B. Carus, of Michigan. Some of them are extraordinary milkers. One of our cows, Rosy 4th, is an extra milker. She has given through the milking season a trifle over forty pounds per day, for three months, and at one of the institutes held here, it showed six per cent, butter-fat. This was a winter test. Mollie Jane 2d is an unusually good milker. I kept a daily record of her milk at the same time, and her milk was tested with Babcock tester. She showed seven and one-fourth per cent. butter-fat; the daily yield of milk of forty-two and one-half pounds. Their feed was wild hay and two pints meal, equal parts of corn and oats, and thirty pounds of beets. There is another cow in the neighborhood, but not recorded, which makes on an average two pounds per day during the summer. This I consider good. I also find that the fat particles are very fine, as a rule requiring a little longer time for the cream to rise, and after you have secured what you can by the common method of standing from twelve to thirty-six hours the milk is still rich. I have never seen a can or a jar of poor milk from the Galloway. I have been told by a friend of mine that the milk of the Galloway was the best of any he knew for feeding infants. The butter seems quite firm in texture, standing the heat of summer, keeping in form without melting or having an oily appearance. It has always recommended itself to our customers.

http://encyclopedia2.thefreedictionary.com/Butterfat+Content
Butterfat content is expressed in percentage. The average fat content of milk from various animal species is as follows (in percent): cows, 3.9; goats, 4.3; sheep, 7.2; swine, 5.9; water buffaloes, 7.7; zebus, 7.0; yaks, 6.8; camels, 5.0; horses, 1.8; asses, 1.4; and reindeer, 18.7. The butterfat content is a breed character, the highest being in Jersey cows (5–6 percent) and the lowest in Holstein-Friesian cows (3.35–3.75 percent). The butterfat content varies in the same breed from zone to zone and with the individual characteristics of the animal and changes little with age. It is higher in fall and winter than in spring and summer. The fat content of milk during the day differs only with the length of time between milkings; the last portion of milk contains more fat than the first.

And a good article, Much Ado About Marbling
http://www.qlf.com/docindexer-76.html
 

Mark H

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
645
Here is a study that actually measured milk production in diffrent beef populations including butterfat: http://pubs.aic.ca/doi/pdf/10.4141/cjas84-032
Note the breed with the highest betterfat is the Hereford.  The othe breeds used were the beef synthetic ( approx 30% Angus, 30% Charolais, 30% Galloway), Dairy Synthetic (30% Angus , 30% Holstein, 30% Brown Swiss), and purebred Hereford.  This is the most extensive work on comparing the  milk characteristics of different beef lines I have seen.  I would like to see MZARC do this work a bigger number of breeds.
 

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
Thanks for the good reading. I wonder what became of the University of Alberta synthetic beef herd? Seems like a very useful cross.
Rummaging around the references cited, I arrived at this paper from 1970. If we assume we now inhabit the future he is projecting, have we achieved those goals? Maybe Larry Leonhardt came close.
Selection Criteria for Beef Cattle for the Future1
http://www.journalofanimalscience.org/content/30/5/706.abstract
Summary
What the future holds is hazardous to predict and invites speculation but some trends are apparent. There will be increased emphasis on traits important for: (1) increasing output/input on a herd rather than individual basis, (2) specialized herds or breeds and (3) utilizing hybrid vigor. Evaluation criteria will be based on more discriminating classification than the customary dairy or beef. Classifications will include consideration of produce, market, breeding system and management system. Specialization will increase in commercial production and seedstock production. Breeds will emphasize selection goals for either sire lines or dam lines or both but in different herds, i.e., emphasis will shift from general purpose to special purpose cattle for both breeds and for breeders. F1's will become recognized and merchandized similarly to registered purebreds. Purebred associations will embrace the F1 and may introduce genes from exotic and dairy sources to broaden their genetic base and to enhance speed of specialization.
 

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
Knabe, this zoo archeology will keep me busy for awhile.
I was always sad that the Chestnut tree planted over Comet's grave was grubbed out when it became huge, and Comets skeleton put in a glass case. Now I learn that the most of the bones were taken as souvenirs. Poor Comet.

Also, interesting that the farmers in India disliked the Jersey cross the experts advised to improve their dairy cattle. The cross made the milk too THIN over that of the native type.
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    87.3 KB · Views: 332

Mark H

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
645
The synthetic lines developed at the university of Alberta ranch ar still going strong.  They are a milticolored group of very useful cattle.  You can buy bulls from this operation but be warned their is a waiting list.  They have every color in the galloway herd book which is to say many.
 

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
Cowman, they could just look for low milk combined with high weaning weight and make a good guess. (smile)

Mark H, did they use any red Charolais in the Synthetic? I think a stout dun Galloway bull on a moderate red Charolais cow would make a great brood cow.

And now a kind of tiresome question.
I'm always wondering about AI and how the same semen might show a range of phenotypic expression depending on the geographic environment of the cow and the type of management during gestation and "calfhood".

I wandered into this paper, which even though they are modeling instead of observing, gets interesting in the discussion.
Effects of sex and age on genotype × environment interaction for beef cattle body weight studied using reaction norm models
http://www.journalofanimalscience.org/content/89/11/3410.full
This is the part I am curious about
Quote:
....It implies that sexually divergent selection can occur within the progeny of a single sire. Male progenies seem to be able to test environments as specialists, keeping information for just 1 environment, leaving females as generalists, with the genetic libraries from old times driven slowly by the male environmental information: a proper asynchronous evolution....
... Rice (1996), Gatford et al. (1998), and West-Eberhard (2003) have shown processes that corroborate the idea that Y chromosome evolution favors epistasis. Such discussions are beyond the objectives of this study, but a hypothesis of environmental dependent expression linked to sexual chromosomes is coherent and suggests a new direction for causality studies, mainly considering different gene expression connected to genotype by environment, sex, and development interactions. Mittwoch (1996) asserted that the primary decision of sex-determining mechanisms may not be males vs. females, or testis vs. ovary, but big vs. small or fast vs. slow growth in embryonic development. In fact, our results show that genotype, environment, sex, and development interact, not only in the embryonic phase, but also after birth and through a big part of the bovine lifetime....
So, the DNA in frozen semen is interactive with environmental triggers?
My main question: is the trigger pulled at collection or at conception?


And does this paper, that I cannot read because I am not in a University, answer any part of that question? Thanks.
Sexual Conflict and Seminal Fluid Proteins: A Dynamic Landscape of Sexual Interactions
http://cshperspectives.cshlp.org/content/early/2014/12/11/cshperspect.a017533.short?rss=1
 

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
I just glanced at related topics and see knabe was plowing this ground in 2009.
What did you find out?
I had just been thinking of trying to milk one of the Galloways and just test the milk somehow.
 

Cabanha Santa Isabel - BR

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 15, 2012
Messages
605
Location
Rio Grande - RS - Brazil
Some years ago under my MsC study I used ONE Belted Galloway on trial. The study was refering milk production on beef cattle. With this unique Belted Galloway I run some Shorthorns too.
I got 3,78% protein content average (3,14 - 5,00); 4,88% lactosis (4,66 - 5,29); 8,94% solids (5 - 11,14).
Also was studied fat content, but I need chech the correct values as well and soon will post here.
The months on study were very very dry, one of the worst droughties that we had on last 40 years here.
Don't forgot that these contents as well as milk production is affected by food and weather.
Also was only one cow, not a significative data.
 

Mark H

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
645
When the Univesity of bought the ranch at Kinsella in 1960 for around $ 15.00 an acre abd the synthetic breeding program was founded.  The idea of a Purebred Charolais other than white would have been a scandal.  red chaolas we not deamed of.  They were just happy to get purebred bulls to use.
Duane Nichols at High Prairie used Red Galloway on purebred charolais cows to get a better crossbred cow than he felt he couold get using red angus bulls: http://www.canadiancattlemen.ca/2010/03/08/heifers-are-his-focus-now/
 

knabe

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 7, 2007
Messages
13,639
Location
Hollister, CA
librarian said:
I just glanced at related topics and see knabe was plowing this ground in 2009.
What did you find out?
I had just been thinking of trying to milk one of the Galloways and just test the milk somehow.


I found out it doesn't merit investigation as beef people aren't interested in anything remotely resembling dairy issues.


All one has to do is get some drop calves and feed them different % butterfat for starters.


Personally, beef people are wedded to phenotype and the scale and are interested in little else.
 

librarian

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
1,629
Location
Knox County Nebraska
Well, preoccupation with phenotype is just the Universe having fun with us.
What is fascinating me is this evolutionary arms race, or antagonistic coevolution between the sexes.
What increases the fitness of the male may decrease the fitness of the female. For example large size benefits males but not females.
Natural populations have mechanisms to even things out, female choice being the trump on male  extremism.
In cattle breeding, we effectively have small isolated populations where we impose mate choice on the females.
So.....no wonder the breeds are so messed up.

But, really- I am thinking that getting around this conflict of chromosomal agendas may be the magic in half sib matings.
Why limit your investigations to things other people are interested in?

Adaptive Strategies, a poem by Leigh Van Valen
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/18310184/songs/adaptive%20strategies.pdf
 
Top