I would not classify the job Mr. Williams did "a joke." He spent a lot of time with the kids and gave them all a fair shot in showmanship and took his time evaluating the cattle. What you didn't hear was a set of reasons with a lot of fluff added in. He gave his reasons in a plain, simple way that even a rookie could understand. His reasons matched his placings and even if you didn't agree with him it was hard to argue with what he saying because it was pretty obvious the flaw was there. Maybe his priorities are lined up a little different than yours.