AAOK you are SOOO right! We had an awesome day today; we have three falls to halter break, a January, a February, two Marches, and two Aprils. We have never had more than two to halter break! We started with the October, about a week ago, put a halter on her in the chute, then hooked her to the tractor to pull her to the barn (she was about 1000 feet in another pasture). She has a nasty attitude anyway, but she has not settled down much in a week now. We keep her in a 12 x 24 run at night and leave a rope halter that has a foot rope on it to make it easier to catch her. She is a snot, and jumps up at you when you ask her to lead. Tonight, my daughter decided to clip on her and got her in the grooming chute. When she removed the halter to clip, she had a huge sore on her chin, I assume from pulling her with the tractor. No wonder she jumps up when you ask her to go forward. Now, for the November, we just picked her up on Saturday last week. She leads EVERYWHERE without any problems already. My 9 year old can lead her. She was VERY hungry and skinny when we got her, so her desire for food was much stronger and I think helped to get her to lead and be around much better. Plus her attitude is awesome, no jumpiness or quirks. She was never drug by the tractor, but just gently tugged towards us in a circle to walk forward. Two different methods, two different outcomes. Today, we pulled in the cows with Feb/March calves (both old show heifers) and cornered the calves (both bulls) and put halters on. We walked them about 50 feet to tie to pipe corral. After about an hour tied, we pulled them around in a circle, gently, got them in the grooming chute and clipped them a bit. I was feeling pretty confidant so I went to the pasture down the hill where the other fall was (a bull born in December that weighs about 600 pounds!). Got him in a 24 x 24 pen and just followed him with a show stick, rubbing all over, until he slowed down and allowed me to put a halter on with the assistance of the show stick. I tied him to the fence and left him for about 30 minutes while I went and checked on the younger calves and played with them, then back down to the big bull calf. My 14 year old daughter untied him and pulled him in a circle around her and had her hands all over him and he was AWESOME!
So, coming from someone who has only broke a few calves, taking it slow and easy was much better. Better outcome for the calves and my body!!!!