I just dont understand

Help Support Steer Planet:

firesweepranch

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 17, 2010
Messages
1,685
Location
SW MO
there is a sale on Willoughby auctions where a particular bull went for $1700 per straw for his semen! They had ten different lots that each had one straw of semen, and each lot sold $1700 or higher.  It takes three straws to make a flush, so that is $5100 in just semen expenses. How can someone afford that? I have nothing against the bull, just wondering why he costs so much and how people justify that expense? Or am I reading it wrong?

here is the sale
http://www.maxanet.com/cgi-bin/mnlist.cgi?willoughby5/category/ALL
 

Grousepark

Active member
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
34
Location
Colorado
Supply and Demand...emotion, adrenaline, and speculation;  Economics:  Hopefully it will turn out great!
 

Showin a Shorty

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 23, 2011
Messages
87
If you take that one unit and use it in IVF you could fert around 5 cows to it (providing the semen is decent quality). Last IVF cycle we did we transferred 9 embryos and got 6 pregs. If you multiply that 5 x 6 your up to around 30 pregs from that one unit of semen. Now with a bull this "hot" I'm sure you could sell the calves for a decent premium (again providing they are of decent quality). It might not make sense at first but there is a lot of technology to help stretch rare or expensive semen.
 

johnmetzger

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 24, 2010
Messages
215
I have success with 2 straws on flushes but still more money than I care to spend.
 

vcsf

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 21, 2009
Messages
294
Location
Saskatchewan, Canada
redirtroad said:
Ohio1 said:
That was a good deal on monopoly
AGREE! wish I would have gotten in on that deal

Could someone explain to me what I am missing that makes this a good deal on Monopoly.  If I am reading correctly you got 5 straws of Monopoly and 5 straws of Monopoly 2 and it cost either $700 or $750 plus you were responsible for shipping.  Is the retail value of this not only $750 with Monopoly at $100 and Monopoly 2 at $50?


With regard to the $1700 a straw semen I saw that at Denver they sold 3 straws of semen on an old bull at $5250 per straw.  How would you like to be using that?
 
C

cornish

Guest
since when is Double Stuff semen worth 35? Every distributor still calls it $15.
 

breyfarm

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 18, 2011
Messages
116
Location
OH
vcsf said:
redirtroad said:
Ohio1 said:
That was a good deal on monopoly
AGREE! wish I would have gotten in on that deal

Could someone explain to me what I am missing that makes this a good deal on Monopoly.  If I am reading correctly you got 5 straws of Monopoly and 5 straws of Monopoly 2 and it cost either $700 or $750 plus you were responsible for shipping.  Is the retail value of this not only $750 with Monopoly at $100 and Monopoly 2 at $50?


With regard to the $1700 a straw semen I saw that at Denver they sold 3 straws of semen on an old bull at $5250 per straw.  How would you like to be using that?
Well  i dont know about you but 50 bucks is 50 bucks and most places your going to pay shipping for that amount and times that by 3 or 4 lots..
 

woltemathangus

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 1, 2011
Messages
241
Location
Nebraska
Uncle told me a good story, he said him and a buddy were AIing a few years ago and his buddy about died when he put a straw of Baldridge Bob (i believe) in a cow. the semen was worth almost 5000 a straw.  (lol)
 

justintime

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2007
Messages
4,346
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
Why is there semen selling at $1700 per straw? The same reason there is tractors and combines selling for $350,000 each and 4X4 trucks selling for $65000-$70000. This reason is simply because there are people williing to pay that for these things. Whether it is a $1700 straw of semen, a $50,000 show heifer, or a $500,000 house, they usually only sell if the buyer thinks they are getting value or prestige. I suspect the buyers of the $1700/straw of semen are thinking they got value for their money.
 

firesweepranch

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 17, 2010
Messages
1,685
Location
SW MO
justintime said:
Why is there semen selling at $1700 per straw? The same reason there is tractors and combines selling for $350,000 each and 4X4 trucks selling for $65000-$70000. This reason is simply because there are people williing to pay that for these things. Whether it is a $1700 straw of semen, a $50,000 show heifer, or a $500,000 house, they usually only sell if the buyer thinks they are getting value or prestige. I suspect the buyers of the $1700/straw of semen are thinking they got value for their money.

So true! so true.... has anyone heard of that bull? I am not an Angus breeder, so I am clueless!
 

justintime

Well-known member
Joined
May 26, 2007
Messages
4,346
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
In regards to the amount of semen used in a flush, I am going to be doing several flushes for an Aussie breeder in the next few months. We had a phone conversation this afternoon and he was telling me how they have been flushing 4 donors from one straw of semen with excellent results. He said the technician has to know what he/ she is doing and a small amount of semen is placed right in the entrance of the follopian tube on  each horn of the uterus. He said they have had excellent results with 10- 14 grade 1 embryos from 4 donors and 1 straw of semen. He is wanting me to do this, as he wants to use some very rare semen of which we only have two vials and don't know of any more. I don't think I have the expertise to do this so I need to find someone with far more tech experience than I do. I have not heard of anyone in North America  flushing in this manner but this Aussie breeder says he has done it on several occasions with rare semen and has never had a bad flush yet. I'm still not totally convinced though.!

If you could flush 4 donors with one straw of $1700 semen, and get 40-50 embryos....  it starts to look like a smarter economical decision.
 

woltemathangus

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 1, 2011
Messages
241
Location
Nebraska
firesweepranch said:
justintime said:
Why is there semen selling at $1700 per straw? The same reason there is tractors and combines selling for $350,000 each and 4X4 trucks selling for $65000-$70000. This reason is simply because there are people williing to pay that for these things. Whether it is a $1700 straw of semen, a $50,000 show heifer, or a $500,000 house, they usually only sell if the buyer thinks they are getting value or prestige. I suspect the buyers of the $1700/straw of semen are thinking they got value for their money.

So true! so true.... has anyone heard of that bull? I am not an Angus breeder, so I am clueless!

Dameron First Class won Denver
 
Top