I have seen a lot of judges and I would rank Jim Williams as being in the top 1-2 % of those I have seen. I have not always agreed with his places ( but normally I do) but he has always provided excellent reasons for what he has done. That is all anyone could ask of any judge.
Personally I have seen several other judges that I found very easy to follow, but I am getting very tired of hearing their " canned" college reasons. They are OK for the first few times you hear them but after awhile, I find myself throwing up in my mouth a bit when I hear them. Jim Williams is a great teacher, and he gives reasons that are meaningful and real, not just some flowery comments the judge learned from his college judging coach. I respect the man and feel he is one of the real good ones in the beef industry. IMO, I would listen to every word he has to say. They usually make sense.