1- for me.. I think there's more true depth/ dimension in that female. even though she appears to me to be fatter- especially about the brisket area. Cattle fatted front front to rear- so she's prob got more body and fat behind that point as well.
I just see a little more legit heifer there. 2 prob has the advantage of muscle- based on her forarm, and rear end-- but she appears narrowers from chest down, and back.
Awefully hard to seperate these two though based on two photos that are almost identical. To me, a rear 3/4 view would seperate them quite easily. A straight from behind might not be bad- but not the most ideal picture.
So I guess with that said, I'd buy 1 from the picture, but who knows what I'd do in person-- double my money and take both????? make sure I bought the right one? Why stop at one, if you're looking to start or build on a herd, may as well make it worth your while to have two similar ones to play around with.